This correspondence will disclose the reasons which have led to the
cancellation by the Mandal of my appointment as President and the reader will
be in a position to lay the blame where it ought properly to belong. This is I
believe the first time when the appointment of a President is cancelled by the
Reception Committee because it does not approve of the views of the President.
But whether that is so or not, this is certainly the first time in my life to
have been invited to preside over a Conference of Caste Hindus. I am sorry that
it has ended in a tragedy. But what can any one expect from a relationship so
tragic as the relationship between the reforming sect of Caste Hindus and the
self-respecting sect of Untouchables where the former have no desire to
alienate their orthodox fellows and the latter have
no alternative but to insist upon reform being carried
out ?
Dadar, Bombay 14 15th May 1936 B. R. AMBEDKAR
Dr.
B. R. Ambedkar
FOR
The 1936 Annual Conference of the Jat-Pat-Todak Mandal of Lahore
BUT NOT DELIVERED
Owing to the
cancellation of the Conference by the Reception Committee on the ground that
the views expressed in the Speech would be unbearable to the Conference
Friends,
I am really
sorry for the members of the Jat-Pat-Todak Mandal who have so very kindly invited
me to preside over this Conference. I am sure they will be asked many questions
for having selected me as the President. The Mandal will be asked to explain as
to why it has imported a man from Bombay to preside over a function which is
held in Lahore. I believe the Mandal could easily have found some one better
qualified than myself to preside on the occasion. I have criticised the Hindus.
I have questioned the authority of the Mahatma whom they revere. They hate me.
To them I am a snake in their garden. The Mandal will no doubt be asked by the
politically-minded Hindus to explain why it has called me to fill this place of
honour. It is an act of great daring. I shall not be surprised if some
political Hindus regard it as an insult. This selection of mine cannot
certainly please the ordinary religiously-minded Hindus. The Mandal may be
asked to explain why it has disobeyed the Shastric
injunction in selecting the President. Accoding to the Shastras the Brahmin is appointed to be the Guru for the three Varnas, varnanam bramhano garu, is a
direction of the Shastras. The Mandal
therefore knows from whom a Hindu should take his lessons and from whom he
should not. The Shastras do not
permit a Hindu to accept any one as his Guru merely because he is well versed.
This is made very clear by Ramdas, a Brahmin saint from Maharashtra, who is
alleged to have inspired Shivaji to establish a Hindu Raj. In his Dasbodh, a socio-politico-religious
treatise in Marathi verse Ramdas
asks, addressing the Hindus, can we accept an Antyaja to be our Guru because he
is a Pandit (i.e. learned) and gives
an answer in the negative. What replies to give to these questions is a matter
which I must leave to the Mandal. The Mandal knows best the reasons which led
it to travel to Bombay to select a president, to fix upon a man so repugnant to
the Hindus and to descend so low in the scale as to select an Antyaja— an
untouchable—to address an audience of the Savarnas.
As for myself you will allow me to say that I have accepted the invitation much
against my will and also against the will of many of my fellow untouchables. I
know that the Hindus are sick of me. I know that I am not a persona grata with them. Knowing all
this I have deliberately kept myself away from them. I have no desire to inflict
myself upon them. I have been giving expression to my views from my own
platform. This has already caused a great deal of heartburning and irritation.
I have no desire to ascend the platform of the Hindus to do within their sight
what I have been doing within their hearing. If I am here it is because of your
choice and not because of my wish. Yours is a cause of social reform. That
cause has always made an appeal to me and it is because of this that I felt I
ought not to refuse an opportunity of helping the cause especially when you
think that I can help it. Whether what I am going to say today will help you in
any way to solve the problem you are grappling with is for you to judge. All I
hope to do is to place before you my views on the problem.
NEXT- II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII XIII XIV XV XVII XVIII XIX XX XXI XXII XXIII XXIV XXV
Comments
Social Counter